Herd Immunity
Herd immunity means that enough people have had a disease, that the contagion can't spread and dies out.
~ Aristotle Sabouni
Created: 2020-04-28 |
Herd immunity means that enough people have had a disease, that the contagion can't spread and dies out. (Basically the effective R0, or how many people each person with the disease passes it on to, is less than 1 other person). This belief leads to misconceptions.
- Some people think that needs to be 60 or 80% of the population. Oversimplified: a disease with an R0 of 3 would require >66% of the population to have immunity so that more than 2 out of 3 people it tried to pass it to, would already have immunity -- dropping the transfer rate below 1.0 and the disease would die out. Basically, true, but there's more to it.
- Herd immunity stacks on other measures: so if you can reduce a contagion to spreading 1/2 as fast by social distancing, hand sanitization, masks, etc., then the R0 of 3.0 is now effectively a 1.5. Which loosely means that if >33% (1 in 3) people already has it, that slows it by an additional 33%, and you're below 1.0, and it would die out. Behavior/culture modifies transfer speed (R0).
- Distribution vectors also matter. Not everyone is equally at risk from everyone else. We have cliques and social circles (clusters/tribes). Someone in BF Idaho doesn't have an equal threat from someone in NYC or Wuhan as from their neighbor or family, because they interact with them slower and less often. If the people immunized are all the people that travel from NYC to BF Idaho, then it doesn't matter if anyone in Idaho has herd immunity, because you cut off the threads of transfer. So inoculating the 5% that travel, could offer significant protections for the other 95% of the sub-population.
This is why the 1918 Spanish Flu Pandemic only infected only 30% of the population -- and NOT 80% required to get theoretical herd immunity.
There was a common sense post that some claimed was "controversial" that basically explained that since 1/3rd of people are responsible for over 2/3rd of interactions, her immunity happens faster than requiring everyone to be equally immunized. The idea is simple and obvious, even if the numbers can be disputed -- but since some people either don't understand common sense, or want the problem to be bigger than it is, they attack sources that point out obvious things like this. [1]
🗒️ Note: |
---|
Simulations that don't show this clustering, or high transmission versus low transmission vectors, are fundamentally dishonest/misleading. |
🔗 More
| |
| |
| |
🔗 Links
Tags: COVID Terms COVID/Science